The New Taste of the Old West.

Enjoy this fresh culinary experience in a historic and elegant atmosphere. No matter when you stop in, you will be in the well-trained hands of our executive chef  — so stop at Theodore’s and treat yourself.

All taste buds are treated equally at Theodore’s. From Fresh Garden Salads and delectable Brussel Sprouts to Bacon-wrapped Steaks and tantalizing Buffalo Osso Bucco, Theodore’s Dining Room has something for everyone! Look over our menus — and we’ll see you for dinner!


Casual attire accepted

No reservations necessary



7:00 AM – 10:00 AM



5:00 PM – 9:00 PM

Dinner Menu


Pork Belly


Alabama white BBQ with green onion

Brussel Sprouts


In house buffalo sauce and gorgonzola crumbles


Bison Osso Bucco


Braised buffalo shanks, red wine, garlic mashed potatoes, balsamic red onions, green beans, demi-glace, creamy horseradish - GF

Beef Tenderloin


7oz fillet, garlic mashed, gorgonzola cream sauce, demi-glace, seasonal vegetables - GF



Pan-seared walleye fillet with Brabant potatoes, beurre blanc and roasted asparagus

Wild Mushroom Pappardelle


Wild mushroom cream sauce with asparagus, cherry tomato and squash. GF option available. | Add chicken $5 | Add half lobster tail $12

Alabama White BBQ Airline Chicken Breast


Pan-seared with root vegetable hash and asparagus - GF

12 oz. Ribeye


Char crusted with wild mushroom demi, root vegetable hash and crispy onions

Teddy’s Burger


Half-pound wagyu beef patty, bacon, shredded lettuce, cheddar, and pimento cheese

Breakfast Menu

Teddy’s Favorite


2 eggs, breakfast potatoes, choice of bacon or sausage & toast

Steak and Eggs


6 oz. sirloin, 2 eggs, breakfast potatoes & toast

Bison Benedict


Braised bison, poached eggs, BBQ hollandaise over an English muffin

Walleye Benedict


Wild rice walleye cake, pouched eggs, citrus hollandaise over an English muffin

Pancake Stack


3 pancakes, 2 eggs, choice of bacon or sausage

Roasted Veggie Hash


Brussel sprout, squash, cherry tomato, asparagus, 2 eggs and toast - GF/Vegetarian

Brioche French Toast


Fruity pebble crusted, cereal milk glaze, choice of bacon or sausage

Wild Rice Porridge


Creamy wild rice with dried cranberries, blueberries, candied pecans and maple syrup

Denver Omelet


Smoked ham, onions, peppers, cheddar cheese, breakfast potatoes and toast

Veggie Omelet


Asparagus, brussel sprout, cherry tomato, squash, choice of cheese and toast

TR's Tavern

3:00 pm- 12:00 am

Located in Theodore’s Dining Room, stop by TR’s Tavern for a craft cocktail, or local beer on tap.

Catering by Theodore’s

Everything you love about Theodore’s Dining Room, brought to you and your group!

Our professional staff at Theodore’s Dining Room can help you create and craft your event, assist you with menu selections, rentals and food services. 

Whether it’s a family reunion or a corporate retreat, you’re in good hands with our Group Sales department!

Planning an event in Medora? Visit our Group Event Services page here!

Additional Details

– Casual attire welcomed — no reservation required
– Reservations available for groups of 8 or more
– 18% gratuity will be added to parties of 8 or more
– Theodore’s will place an 8.00 charge for each split entrée
– Consuming raw or uncooked meats, poultry, shellfish or eggs, may increase your risk of food born illness
– Please inform your server of any food allergies